Recommended by the New York Times, Wine Spectator, Food & Wines, and Many More. Check out our recent Press.

Award-winning NYC wine shop – free local delivery & fast nationwide shipping. Learn more

EXTRA BRUT WINE CLUB JANUARY 2026

Two Truths About Terroir

There's more than one way to get at the essence of a place. Some growers isolate a single grape variety, stripping away blending and dosage to ask: what does Chardonnay really taste like here? Others focus on vintage, capturing what a particular year tasted like in a particular place, using whatever blend of grapes best tells that story. Both approaches are honest. Both can be delicious. This month, we have one of each.

Christophe Mignon is a name you may already know from our shelves or emails, and one you'll likely be hearing more about soon. Antonio Galloni's recent Vinous coverage ("impressive, to say the least") has been glowing, and we suspect Mignon is on the verge of really blowing up. We don't know how long we'll be able to get these wines in any quantity, so we're thrilled to share them with the club now. 

But one of the great thrills of Champagne today is the huge number of tiny, young growers finding their own voices – whether that’s launching new domaines with old family vines, or taking older domaines in more progressive directions. As established masters like Mignon get their due and become highly coveted, we keep discovering remarkable new growers, like Vincent Lagille at Domaine Lagille. 

Vincent is part of a new generation inspired by producers like Mignon. And while their wines are different along many dimensions, they share a fixation on getting to the heart of what makes their respective corners of Champagne unique.

EXTRA BRUT PICK NO. 1

Our thoughts on this selection

Christophe Mignon comes from a long line of farmers in the hamlet of Le-Mesnil-le-Huttier, about 13 miles west of Épernay in the Vallée de la Marne. 

But being part of an ancient tradition doesn’t mean you can’t experiment and try to find something new. Mignon has done plenty of that and developed his own approach to viticulture, sometimes called "the Mignon Method," which combines biodynamics, phytotherapy, homeopathy, and geobiology. He follows the lunar calendar for everything related to water, oxygen, and gas, both in the vineyard and the cellar. He has even designed his own tools, including custom tractor blades and a homeopathy machine that dilutes copper with valerian root and garlic. 

But this isn’t experimentation for its own sake. He likens nature to a Rubik's cube, always presenting new challenges, and he revels in finding solutions. There's a bit of the mad scientist in Mignon, but it's all in service of one goal: letting the terroir speak.

"ADN" is French for DNA, and each wine in the series isolates a single grape variety to reveal its essence. A 100% Chardonnay cuvée may be an outlier for a Pinot Meunier specialist, but it shows what Mignon's methods – and skills – can do with any grape. The soils here are about two feet of clay-limestone topsoil over chalk and limestone tuffeau. The wine is fermented and aged in large oak foudres, with no dosage and minimal sulfur.

The result is striking, intensely vinous, with the feel of a still Chardonnay with a bit of mousse. It is a wine that conveys the limestone site in a flat-out delicious Chardonnay framing: laser-focused and mineral with citrus peel, white flowers, lemon confit, and marzipan notes. It isn’t a wine we expect from Vallée de la Marne, but it is exactly the kind of surprise that makes Champagne so endlessly fascinating. You may want to drink it on its own, a sort of wine of contemplation. We certainly do! But don’t be afraid to pair it with a shellfish-forward dinner or even risotto – that vinous quality makes it a natural for elevated pairings.

EXTRA BRUT PICK NO. 2

Our thoughts on this selection

Vincent Lagille’s family has been making wine in Treslon since 1818, but Vincent is part of the new guard, a generation of growers inspired by producers like Mignon. The village is in the Vallée de l'Ardre – about 15 miles from Mignon, and a traditional transition area between the Montagne de Reims and Valle de la Marne. The family is devoted to that terroir. 

Vincent joined his sister Maud at the domaine in 2012 and has been driving the family toward more progressive farming and winemaking ever since. The turning point came in 2017 when, in his words, “I had a click... It became crystal clear. I wanted local wines. Wines that tell about our roots. Family roots, but also cultural roots. For this, I wanted the terroir to be able to express itself, for the vine to be able to draw deep into the soil." 

The Au Fil du Temps is Lagille’s vintage wine, and it takes a different approach than Mignon's ADN. Where Mignon isolates variety, here Lagille isolates the year, blending whatever combination of grapes and plots best capture what 2020 tasted like in the village of Treslon. This village focus is also an ever-so-slightly zoomed out approach to terroir than Lagille takes with his single-site bottling. In Vincent’s words, again: “Here the elaboration process has been ‘overturned.’ The vintage Champagnes tell the story of a terroir, Treslon, of a single year, but are most of the time the result of a blend of grape varieties.”

The 2020 Fil du Temp is a blend of 55% Pinot Noir, 35% Meunier, and 10% Chardonnay. The dosage is low at 3 g/L – less extreme than Mignon's zero dosage, but still low enough to stay out of the way of the Lagille’s pure terroir and vintage expression (and firmly in Extra Brut territory). The result is a wine crunchy with mineral but generous with 2020 fruit. Elegant and balanced enough for an aperitif, it is also complex enough to elevate a wintry meal, like scallops and roasted parsnip. 

Two growers, two frames

Vincent’s 2020 is clearly inspired by the fearless winemaking of Mignon and his (short list of) contemporaries. But it isn’t one that tries to emulate Mignon’s work; rather, it emulates Mignon’s sense of freedom to do whatever it takes to express his own terroir.