Recommended by the New York Times, Wine Spectator, Food & Wines, and Many More. Check out our recent Press.

Award-winning NYC wine shop – free local delivery & fast nationwide shipping. Learn more

Old Overholt, Rye 4 Year Whiskey

Spirit from New York, United States
by Old Overholt
$26.99
Taxes and shipping calculated at checkout.
Use code 10OFF to get 10% off 12+ bottles

Old Overholt is one of America’s oldest whiskey brands, with roots dating back to 1810. Known as the bartender’s rye, this Pennsylvania-born, Kentucky-made whiskey has been a staple in classic cocktails for generations. Aged for four years—longer than many entry-level ryes—it delivers a well-rounded balance of spice, sweetness, and subtle oak influence.

On the palate, expect a mix of baking spices, toasted grain, and a touch of vanilla, all carried by rye’s signature peppery edge. Unlike high-proof or ultra-aged ryes, Old Overholt 4 Year leans into approachability, making it as easy to sip neat as it is to mix into a Manhattan or Old Fashioned.

Reliable, versatile, and packed with history, this is a must-have rye for both whiskey lovers and cocktail enthusiasts. Enjoy it on the rocks, in a classic rye cocktail, or as an everyday sipper with plenty of character.

Shipping

Every step of the journey is managed to uphold the integrity of each bottle.

  • Nationwide Access: Flat-rate shipping available to most U.S. states with delivery in 3-5 business days.
  • Temperature-Monitored Shipping: We closely monitor weather conditions and make informed decisions to ensure shipments travel safely, with insulated packaging and refrigerated transport available when required.
  • Wine-Specific Protective Packaging: Specialized materials designed to maintain label integrity and prevent breakage during transit.
  • Provenance Assured: All wines are maintained in climate-controlled conditions at our shop until the moment of dispatch.

Returns & Exchanges

We stand behind every bottle we sell.

  • Corked wine? Full refund or exchange within 60 days
  • Damaged shipment? Contact us within 48 hours
  • Storage or quality concerns? We're here to help


View our complete return policy →

Have Questions?

Our team is here to help.

Hours

Sunday - Thursday: 12 pm - 8 pm

Friday: 11am - 9pm

Saturday: 10am - 9pm

Email: help@flatiron-wines.com
Phone: (212) 477-1315

More about Old Overholt

Founded in 1810 in West Overton, Pennsylvania, Old Overholt is America's oldest continually maintained whiskey brand. The rye moved around—from Pennsylvania to Kentucky via Jim Beam, then into the Suntory empire—but it's never stopped being made. There's a rugged, unadorned honesty to Old Overholt, as if it doesn't care much about reputation but earned it anyway. A relic that actually tastes like its origins.

Wine Details

  • Size

    750ml

Flatiron's Take

From the Importer

What has to say about this wine:

Tasting Notes & Food Pairings

Perfect Pairings

Tasting Profile


More wines from Old Overholt

View all