Left Continue shopping
Your Order

You have no items in your cart

OCTOBER 2025
Extra Brut Wine Club

Louis Tarlant cared so much about the purity of Champagne, he took to the streets. It was 1911 and some of the big houses had threatened to start trucking grapes from other regions into Champagne. Louis was a local grape grower and the mayor of Oeuilly. He knew if they got away with that, it wouldn’t just be bad for the small farmers, like him. It would be terrible for the overall quality of Champagne and for the region as a whole.

So he and his neighbors – in classic French style – organized blockades to keep the trucks out. And it worked. The trucks turned around. But Louis didn’t stop there. He swore never to sell another grape to a big house, and became a very early estate bottler. He also helped create the Champagne AOC to preserve the purity of Champagne. 

Today Louis, who must have seemed like an absolute punk to the elite of the time,. Today, he seems like a visionary. The Champenois are so protective of their name that it’s become a meme (“anything else is just sparkling X”). And virtually all great Champagnes chase a conception of purity. 

But Champagne is diverse and  producers have different ideas of just what type of purity they are after – and how to achieve it. 

This month, we have two wines that show incredible purity but come at it from very different angles. Both are from the 2016 vintage, both drinking beautifully right now. One focuses everything on a single grape grown on the purest chalk terroir. The other orchestrates six grape varieties from 63 different parcels into something beautifully harmonious. Both are profoundly terroir transparent. Both are honest. Both are delicious.

EXTRA BRUT PICK NO. 1

Our thoughts on this selection

The Franck Bonville estate sits in Avize, right in the heart of the Côte des Blancs. If you want to understand what "grand cru Chardonnay on pure chalk" means in Champagne, this is where you come. And today Olivier Bonville and his son-in-law Ferdinand Ruelle-Dudel are the third and fourth generations at the domaine working to express that terroir.

You don’t have to search to understand what makes the Bonville Champagne so elegant and focused. It is pure Chardonnay, from the legendary chalk soils that give Côte des Blancs wines their singular mineral drive. It is a vintage cuvee from 2016, one of the finest recent vintages and our favorite for drinking at the moment. Their conscientious approach to farming allows all of  these elements to speak: the Bonville’s haven’t used chemical herbicides or pesticides in over a decade and will soon be certified organic..

But even this minimalist expression needs a human touch. Not just the manual tending in the vineyards and the careful monitoring of the fermentation. Even after the long aging in the bottle, Olivier and Ferdinand taste the wine blind testing different levels of dosage (that addition of sugar that traditionally rounded out Champagne’s naturally high acidity). In 2016 they settled on 2.5 g/L of sugar – just a touch and easily qualifying as Extra Brut, but still a human touch and intentional choice that works, like a tiny sprinkle of salt on a dish, to bring focus and clarity to all the other flavors and textures that are already there. 

The wine comes together in the glass like a picture postcard of that single slope in Champagne, in that single year. There’s some richness and ripeness from the late summer 2016 warmth (the family calls it white peach and apricot notes and who are we to argue?). There’s the brioche and decadent texture from the time aging sur-lattes before release. And underneath it all – and especially on the long finish – there is the chalky terroir, salinity, and an alluring herbaceous hint.

Classic Côte des Blancs wines like this are delicious on their own, of course, but are natural pairings with with oysters, crudo, delicate seafood. The 2016's ripe side though, makes it perfect with broader dishes too, like lobster, a crisp-skinned roast chicken or even rich after dinner cheeses. 

EXTRA BRUT PICK NO. 2

Our thoughts on this selection

When Louis Tarlant swore never to sell a single grape to a big house there were fewer than ten independent estates in all of Champagne. Louis’ radical stance helped pave the way for today’s dynamic Champagne  rich with grower producers. 

In the late 1970s, Louis’ great-grandson, Jean-Mary, did something that seemed just as radical as blocking the roads: he started bottling Champagne with zero dosage. This was unheard of at the time. The conventional wisdom was that Champagne was too acidic to drink without the softening effect of added sugar. In fact, the French supposedly called drier Champagne “Brut” because it was the brutish English who kept asking for lower and lower dosages.  

But Jean-Mary believed that with conscientious  farming on serious terroir, they could make Champagne that was best without any dosage at all. Jean-Mary’s son, Benoît carries on the legacy. "The goal," he explains, "is to express a Champagne without the external sugar masking the land's characteristics." It really works and today zero dosage defines the Tarlant style. Ninety percent of their production is bottled without dosage, with this "Zéro" cuvée representing roughly 70% of their total output.

The first thing you will probably note when you open the wine is the bracing purity: fruit, acidity, and minerality. That’s in part thanks to the zero dosage, of course. But Benoît and his sister Mélanie, who joined the family business in 2003, make many choices to achieve that goal: the farming is organic, the wines don’t go through malolactic fermentation (a second fermentation which sometimes occurs and changes tense malic acidity into gentler lactic acid). The wines are bottled unfined and unfiltered.

But for a wine called “Zero” there’s a surprising amount of orchestration. Tarlant's is in the Vallée de la Marne, not the Côte des Blancs, and their soils vary considerably: clay, sand, limestone, and flint. Rather than isolating one element, they lean into that diversity, blending 63 individual parcels to make, not a pure snapshot of a single soil, but of the Marne’s special, if variegated, terroir.  

And they don't work with just one grape, or even limit themselves to the big three (Chardonnay, Pinot Noir and Pinot Meunier). They use six, including equal parts of those three blended with three of Champagne's "forgotten grapes": Pinot Blanc, Arbane, and Petit Meslier. This isn't some modern experiment; these grapes are an ancient part of Champagnois tradition and, in the Tarlant’s estimation, the 4% they represent of the final blend is an essential part of any true picture of their terroir. 

Like the Bonville, the Tarlant is 2016-focused; but unlike the Bonville, it includes about 40% reserve wines, bringing depth and additional complexity to the ripe yet nervy 16.  

The precision of those 63 individual vinifications allows them to orchestrate a panoramic view of what Vallée de la Marne terroir can be. You taste the diversity of soils, the interplay of six different grapes, the time-traveling effect of reserve wines, but it all comes together as a unified expression. Nothing obscures the land—no dosage, no malo, no filtration—but you're seeing everything that their vineyards can produce when given this level of care.

The Tarlant's complexity and zero dosage mean it can handle richer foods while staying refreshing through multiple courses. Will it be good with oysters? Yes, sure. But if you’re having a miso ramen with lots of mushrooms and a fatty piece of pork, well, a glass of the Talant will take your takeout to the next level. 

What counts is what’s in the bottle

Bonville and Tarlant both use extreme precision in the vineyard and cellar to make wines of both precision and detailed complexity. We love to describe these wines as“pure” – and they are, even if highly specific and not in identical ways.

But what we take away from these wines is that, although neither producer is dogmatic, they both hold true to their vision. And that honesty, that commitment , makes for sparkling wines that simply couldn’t come from any other region in the world.

We hope you love these as much as we do.



GROWER CHAMPAGNE

A guide to the best bubbles in the world and what makes them different from the Grandes Marques

Champagne is the world’s most famous sparkling wine. Hailing from the Champagne regions of France, its biggest names are among the biggest names in wine: Moet, Dom Perignon, Veuve Clicquot, Cristal.

But there’s another side to Champagne: a universe of small-scale producers preserving ancient family farming traditions and bottling wines you’ve never heard of.

These are the Grower Champagnes.

We're here to help

Have a burning question or just want to connect with our team of fellow Champagne lovers?